Jump to content
Science Forums

Why democracy is so important


Recommended Posts

 I live in Russia, and many people around me call themselves opponents of democracy. Their logic is simple - we can live pretty well without democracy. I will prove that there are holes in this logic.

Currently in the world there are quite prosperous monarchical countries - Jordan, Bahrain, the United Arab Emirates, etc. But these monarchies are very different from the ancient monarchies - Eastern despotism. This is explained by the fact that in modern monarchies, which are adjacent to democracies, the authorities must be good, otherwise they will be overthrown. In civilizations that did not know what democracy in general was, there was such an oppression of the upper classes to the lower classes that it is scary for the reader.

When an authoritarian (for example, a monarchy) state is in the neighborhood of democracy, the authorities in it are afraid of revolution and therefore cannot afford to exploit the population too much. They understand that if the population lives worse than in the neighboring democracy, it will arrange a revolution and change the government to a democratic one. In other words, democracies exert an “ennobling” effect on neighboring authoritarian ones. Despite this impact, these authoritarian countries often pose a military threat to them.

Ancient Macedonia was more civilized than ancient Persia, despite the fact that both of these states were monarchies. This is explained by the fact that Macedonia bordered on Greece with its democratic traditions.

Another example from history is Germany in the first half of the 20th century. Germany was an authoritarian country in the neighborhood of democratic France and England, and these countries exerted an “ennobling” influence on it; thanks to the English and French revolutions, in 20th century Germany there was no serfdom and other vestiges of the Middle Ages. And despite this influence, Germany posed a military threat to England and France.

One more example is the confrontation between medieval Muscovy and the Novgorod Republic. When the Novgorod Republic existed, the peasants both in it and in the Muscovy were relatively free. But after the conquest of Novgorod by Moscow, a gradual enslavement of the peasants began, which reached its peak under Peter the Great.

If democracy in the world is discredited, then the world will slide into the second Middle Ages, and this possibility frightens me very much now. The likelihood of such a scenario will be higher if in current confrontation between Russia and Ukraine the latter is defeated.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


I despair of things ever improving in the world, when so many people do not know the difference between a ""Democracy" and a "Constitutional Republic."

In a DEMOCRACY—THE State is Authorized to do ANYTHING that it can get 50% of the voting public + 1 extra Person to vote for. 

IF you can persuade 50% + 1 Person to vote to execute all the Blue-Eyed People—then this is quite Democratic.

In a CONSTITUTIONAL REPUBLIC, The Charter of the Government recognizes that men are born with Certain INALIENABLE RIGHTS—and NO ONE—not the State; not "Society" and not even "the Majority" have any Moral OR Legal Authorization to abrogate those INDIVIDUAL & INALIENABLE RIGHTS—not for any reason...

To include the most extreme scenario imaginable—not even to save the human race from imminent extinction.

Certainly, in SOME (few) cases, reasonable men may differ on PRECISELY what men's Inalienable rights are—therefore some minor finagling is in order occasionally.

Unfortunately, even having a bang-up Charter is no panacea. Evil Men—and what are worse—PRAGMATISTS—can steadily wear away at the Charter given time. This is precisely where we stand in the New Knighted States today. Constitutions are gradually corrupted by a form of Systemic Senility.

The important thing is:

A REPUBLIC recognizes—at least in principle—they supremacy of The Individual and deliberately tries to muzzle and handcuff the powers of the State.

A DEMOCRACY Idolizes Mob-Rule and collectivism.

I Scringe every time some talking head advocates exporting "DEMOCRACY" to foreign nations. DEMOCRACY is precisely what we DO NOT WANT to burden friendly countries with.

Every bloody war of Genocide going on in the World today—and they happen in Africa with some degree of regularity—is a PERFECT EXAMPLE OF DEMOCRACY IN ACTION...

And yes, the NKS had become increasingly DEMOCRATIC over the last 120 or more years—and as DEMOCRACY HAS WAXED FREEDOM HAS WANED.


Saxon Violence

Edited by SaxonViolence
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Create New...