TonyYuan2020 Posted April 8, 2020 Author Report Share Posted April 8, 2020 (edited) https://photos.app.goo.gl/axeDPZggPZAjComR7Assume that the earth speed v0 = 0. Star began to approach the earth at the speed of v. Star came to position B, and the elapsed time was T seconds. The gravitational changes experienced by the earth are as follows:A: F = G * M * m / R^2B: F = G * M * m / (R + 1000)^2 ≈ G * M * m / R^2According to the law of conservation of momentum:F * T = mv1-mv0 = mv1, then v1 = F * T / m = T * G * M / R^2T = 2s: v1 = 2 * G * M / R^2T = 1s: v1 = 1 * G * M / R^2Because of the speed v of the star, the earth obtained a different speed v1. The larger v is, the larger v1 will be, but the gravitational force on the planet from the star has hardly changed. If the star's v = X * cos(wt), then the speed change of earth will also show volatility.The relative speed between them really affects the speed of the earth. Do you still think there is no Doppler effect between them? If you understand the Doppler effect, you will know that it exists anywhere.When M and m are far away from each other, the greater the relative speed, the smaller the speed change that m can obtain. When M and m are close to each other, the greater the relative speed, the greater the speed change that m can obtain. Isn't this the characteristic of the Doppler effect? Everything can't deny the law of conservation of momentum.https://photos.app.goo.gl/FNohkKDepHhgx2b29To simplify the calculation, we do not consider the displacement in the y direction.F = G*M*m/L^2=G*M*m/(R - r*cos(w*t))^2F * t = mv1-mv0, assume v0=0 then F * t = mv1, then v1 = F * t / m = t*G*M/(R - r*cos(w*t))^2, then v1 = g(t)*t, g(t) = G*M/(R - r*cos(w*t))^2.if R>100r, v1 ≈ t*G*M/R^2 = g*t , g = G*M/R^2.The volatility of the gravitational field is obvious. When the celestial body is relatively far away, the g between them is close to a constant, but when they are relatively close, g is a function of relative speed and time.We has shown that when relative motions between celestial bodies are on the same straight line, the speed change of celestial bodies with mass m is related to the relative speed between them. If the relative speed change shows volatility, then the speed change value v1 will also show volatility. Then the gravitational acceleration g (t) will also show volatility.No matter what gravity is, the affected object will show volatility, it also has a Doppler effect. So I guess: if we can consider the Doppler effect of the gravitational field when calculating the precession of Mercury, then the missing 44.1" will no longer need GR compensation. Edited April 9, 2020 by TonyYuan2020 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyYuan2020 Posted April 8, 2020 Author Report Share Posted April 8, 2020 (edited) https://photos.app.goo.gl/axeDPZggPZAjComR7Assume that the earth speed v0 = 0. Star began to approach the earth at the speed of v. Star came to position B, and the elapsed time was T seconds. The gravitational changes experienced by the earth are as follows:A: F = G * M * m / R^2B: F = G * M * m / (R + 1000)^2 ≈ G * M * m / R^2According to the law of conservation of momentum:F * T = mv1-mv0 = mv1, then v1 = F * T / m = T * G * M / R^2T = 2s: v1 = 2 * G * M / R^2T = 1s: v1 = 1 * G * M / R^2Because of the speed v of the star, the earth obtained a different speed v1. The larger v is, the larger v1 will be, but the gravitational force on the planet from the star has hardly changed. If the star's v = X * cos(wt), then the speed change of earth will also show volatility.The relative speed between them really affects the speed of the earth. Do you still think there is no Doppler effect between them? If you understand the Doppler effect, you will know that it exists anywhere.When M and m are far away from each other, the greater the relative speed, the smaller the speed change that m can obtain. When M and m are close to each other, the greater the relative speed, the greater the speed change that m can obtain. Isn't this the characteristic of the Doppler effect? Everything can't deny the law of conservation of momentum.https://photos.app.goo.gl/FNohkKDepHhgx2b29To simplify the calculation, we do not consider the displacement in the y direction.F = G*M*m/L^2=G*M*m/(R - r*cos(w*t))^2F * t = mv1-mv0, assume v0=0 then F * t = mv1, then v1 = F * t / m = t*G*M/(R - r*cos(w*t))^2, then v1 = g(t)*t, g(t) = G*M/(R - r*cos(w*t))^2.if R>100r, v1 ≈ t*G*M/R^2 = g*t , g = G*M/R^2.The volatility of the gravitational field is obvious. When the celestial body is relatively far away, the g between them is close to a constant, but when they are relatively close, g is a function of relative speed and time.post # 119 has shown that when relative motions between celestial bodies are on the same straight line, the speed change of celestial bodies with mass m is related to the relative speed between them. If the relative speed change shows volatility, then the speed change value v1 will also show volatility. Then the gravitational acceleration g (t) will also show volatility.No matter what gravity is, the affected object will show volatility, it also has a Doppler effect. So I guess: if we can consider the Doppler effect of the gravitational field when calculating the precession of Mercury, then the missing 44.1" will no longer need GR compensation. Edited April 8, 2020 by TonyYuan2020 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyYuan2020 Posted April 8, 2020 Author Report Share Posted April 8, 2020 (edited) Sources of the precession of perihelion for MercuryAmount (arcsec/Julian century)[8]Cause532.3035..................Gravitational tugs of other solar bodies0.0286.....................Oblateness of the Sun (quadrupole moment)42.9799....................Gravitoelectric effects (Schwarzschild-like), a General Relativity effect−0.0020...................Lense–Thirring precession575.31.......................Total predicted574.10±0.65[7]........Observed532.3035" I hope someone can introduce the Doppler effect of the gravitational field and recalculate it.Planet...........Mercury... 5.75"......... 5.50" If the calculation described in the previous section is carried out more accurately, taking into account the slight eccentricities of the planetary orbits, as well as their small mutual inclinations, and retaining many more terms in the expansions (1015) and (1017), then the perihelion precession rate of the planet Mercury is found to be arc seconds per year. However, the observed precession rate is arc seconds per year. It turns out that the cause of this discrepancy is the general relativistic correction to Newtonian gravity.5.50"------------------------->5.32", from these words, there are many things that can be tapped in this calculation model. Maybe you will be the first scholar to calculate the correct data. Introducing the Doppler effect of gravitational field, you may shock the world. Edited April 8, 2020 by TonyYuan2020 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyYuan2020 Posted April 8, 2020 Author Report Share Posted April 8, 2020 Sources of the precession of perihelion for MercuryAmount (arcsec/Julian century)[8]Cause532.3035..................Gravitational tugs of other solar bodies0.0286.....................Oblateness of the Sun (quadrupole moment)42.9799....................Gravitoelectric effects (Schwarzschild-like), a General Relativity effect−0.0020...................Lense–Thirring precession575.31.......................Total predicted574.10±0.65[7]........Observed532.3035" I hope someone can introduce the Doppler effect of the gravitational field and recalculate it.Planet...........Mercury... 5.75"......... 5.50" If the calculation described in the previous section is carried out more accurately, taking into account the slight eccentricities of the planetary orbits, as well as their small mutual inclinations, and retaining many more terms in the expansions (1015) and (1017), then the perihelion precession rate of the planet Mercury is found to be arc seconds per year. However, the observed precession rate is arc seconds per year. It turns out that the cause of this discrepancy is the general relativistic correction to Newtonian gravity.5.50"------------------------->5.32", from these words, there are many things that can be tapped in this calculation model. Maybe you will be the first scholar to calculate the correct data. Introducing the Doppler effect of gravitational field, you may shock the world. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyYuan2020 Posted April 9, 2020 Author Report Share Posted April 9, 2020 Regarding the existence of the Doppler effect in the gravitational field, I have clearly stated that the knowledge I used is the knowledge of classical physics, I believe everyone can understand it. The distance between the planets of our solar system is not far away, and this Doppler effect cannot be ignored by us. The acceleration of gravity in classical physics is an approximate formula g = G * M / R^2 when they are very far away from each other. But when they are relatively close to each other, the results calculated using this formula will have a relatively large deviation. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyYuan2020 Posted April 9, 2020 Author Report Share Posted April 9, 2020 Regarding the existence of the Doppler effect in the gravitational field, I have clearly stated that the knowledge I used is the knowledge of classical physics, I believe everyone can understand it. The distance between the planets of our solar system is not far away, and this Doppler effect cannot be ignored by us. The acceleration of gravity in classical physics is an approximate formula g = G * M / R^2 when they are very far away from each other. But when they are relatively close to each other, the results calculated using this formula will have a relatively large deviation. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyYuan2020 Posted April 11, 2020 Author Report Share Posted April 11, 2020 I have verified with procedures that Mercury's precession deviation (44.1 "per century) is due to the Doppler effect of the gravitational field. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyYuan2020 Posted April 11, 2020 Author Report Share Posted April 11, 2020 (edited) Planet -------- Perihelion precession --------------- Afar precession (per century)------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Mercury********** 58.405"****************** 47.439"Venus********** 38.255"****************** 38.465"Earth********** 32.647"****************** 32.389"Mars********** 28.245"****************** 25.653"Jupiter********** 14.578"****************** 13.836"Saturn********** 10.822"****************** 10.190"Uranus********** 7.454"****************** 7.369"Neptune********** 5.422"****************** 5.302"These data come from program simulation. The planetary precession under the Doppler effect of gravitational field every century. Edited April 11, 2020 by TonyYuan2020 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyYuan2020 Posted April 12, 2020 Author Report Share Posted April 12, 2020 We study a physical force situation, often by observing its speed change. Then under the Doppler effect of the gravitational field, the speed change of the object will also be different from the change under the ordinary gravitational field (non-Doppler effect).I wrote the planetary orbit precession under the action of the Doppler effect of the gravitational field. I found that if I remove this effect, there will be no precession in the planetary orbit, and with the Doppler effect, you can see that there is precession. Precession under the Doppler effect of gravitational field: Planet -------- Perihelion precession ------------ Afar precession (per century) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Mercury********** 58.404"***************** 32.938" Venus********** 38.004"****************** 38.466" Earth********** 33.073"****************** 32.392" Mars********** 27.609"****************** 24.686" Jupiter********** 14.524"****************** 13.042" Saturn********** 10.831"****************** 9.519" Uranus********** 7.446"****************** 6.992" Neptune********** 6.064"***************** 5.929"Precession under the normal gravitational field: (non-Doppler effect) Planet -------- Perihelion precession ---- Afar precession per century ----------------------------------------------------------------------- Mercury********** 0.000"****************** 0.000" Venus********** 0.000"****************** 0.000" Earth********** 0.000"****************** 0.000" Mars********** 0.000"****************** 0.000" Jupiter********** 0.000"****************** 0.000" Saturn********** 0.000"****************** 0.000" Uranus********** 0.000"****************** 0.000" Neptune********** 0.000"****************** 0.000" Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyYuan2020 Posted April 12, 2020 Author Report Share Posted April 12, 2020 Planet -------- Perihelion precession ---- Afar precession per century under the Doppler effect---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Mercury********** 58.404"****************** 32.938"*******meanArc= 43.053"Venus********** 38.004"****************** 38.466"*******meanArc= 38.236"Earth********** 33.073"****************** 32.392"*******meanArc= 32.726"Mars********** 27.609"****************** 24.686"*******meanArc= 26.075"Jupiter********** 14.524"****************** 13.042"*******meanArc= 13.747"Saturn********** 10.831"****************** 9.519"*******meanArc= 10.138"Uranus********** 7.446"****************** 6.992"*******meanArc= 7.209"Neptune********** 6.064"****************** 5.929"*******meanArc= 5.996" Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyYuan2020 Posted April 12, 2020 Author Report Share Posted April 12, 2020 Planet -------- Perihelion precession ---- Afar precession per century under the Doppler effect---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Mercury********** 58.404"****************** 32.938"*******meanArc= 43.053"Venus********** 38.004"****************** 38.466"*******meanArc= 38.236"Earth********** 33.073"****************** 32.392"*******meanArc= 32.726"Mars********** 27.609"****************** 24.686"*******meanArc= 26.075"Jupiter********** 14.524"****************** 13.042"*******meanArc= 13.747"Saturn********** 10.831"****************** 9.519"*******meanArc= 10.138"Uranus********** 7.446"****************** 6.992"*******meanArc= 7.209"Neptune********** 6.064"****************** 5.929"*******meanArc= 5.996" Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyYuan2020 Posted April 12, 2020 Author Report Share Posted April 12, 2020 Mercury********** 58.404"****************** 32.938"*******meanArc= 43.053" Mercury Precession Deviation 43" comes from the Doppler effect of the gravitational field. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyYuan2020 Posted April 12, 2020 Author Report Share Posted April 12, 2020 Mercury********** 58.404"****************** 32.938"*******meanArc= 43.053" Mercury Precession Deviation 43" comes from the Doppler effect of the gravitational field. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyYuan2020 Posted April 12, 2020 Author Report Share Posted April 12, 2020 Mercury********** 58.404"****************** 32.938"*******meanArc= 43.053"Mercury Precession Deviation 43" comes from the Doppler effect of the gravitational field. https://photos.app.goo.gl/D4kgZ8dyzBmpjrux5 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TonyYuan2020 Posted April 12, 2020 Author Report Share Posted April 12, 2020 Mercury********** 58.404"****************** 32.938"*******meanArc= 43.053"Mercury Precession Deviation 43" comes from the Doppler effect of the gravitational field. https://photos.app.goo.gl/D4kgZ8dyzBmpjrux5 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.