Whenever I am digging through my bookshelves and come across E A Poe's Eureka, I find myself asking (silently) if anyone in any field of study ever reads this book. I have never yet spoken with anyone who even knew that he wrote such. I suppose that's because we are concentrated on his horror poems and fiction. Yet, I wonder why it would not be at least suggested reading somewhere along the line. If anyone has read it, I would like to hear thoughts about it and how it was received in what field of study.
It is, of course, religion first but I would call it at least philosophy. Then, to a lesser degree, there is the science he speaks of. Critiques say he was wrong on some predictions and right on others. For example, he predicted that the universe was expanding from a single particle (true so far as we know at present). Then he added that, at a certain point, it would rebound and contract back to a single particle. (Does any scientific theory claim that at present?)
His book received more condemnation than praise but it did receive praise from some outstanding people: "Albert Einstein in a letter written in 1934 noted that ..... Eureka was 'a beautiful achievement of an unusually independent mind'".
The last half of the Wikipedia article is good reading. I have lost the URL but I shall go back to get it and see if I can get back in here with it. Meanwhile, it would be good to hear thoughts from someone who has really read the book with an open mind.
Edited by hazelm, 25 August 2017 - 12:59 PM.